15 Minutes
Cover of How Not to Be Wrong

Science · 15 min

How Not to Be Wrong

Jordan Ellenberg · 2014

Who it's for

For anyone who wants to read news, research, and promises with a more critical eye, without tackling difficult formulas. Also for readers who enjoy curious stories about numbers, lotteries, politics, and science.

Read it in the app

⚡ Free to download • 🎁 One full book free every day

🎧 Listen to this summary in the app

Every summary has audio narration. Open the app to read it or listen to it.

3 ideas to take with you

1

Before believing in a brilliant performance, ask how many competitors were at the starting line and how many disappeared from the story.

2

After an extreme result, things usually move back toward the average, and that may have nothing to do with what you did.

3

Two candidates separated by a narrow gap in a poll may be tied within the margin of error.

“
If you look only at the survivors, you'll draw the wrong lessons about what works.
An idea from How Not to Be Wrong, in the words of 15 Minutes

Preview

Start reading now

Mathematics as reinforced common sense

How Not to Be Wrong, by Jordan Ellenberg, begins with a friendly challenge: mathematics isn't a club of formulas for geniuses, but a tool for avoiding reasoning mistakes that everyone makes. The English title gets straight to that point: how not to be wrong. The idea is that mental math, an intuitive grasp of probability, and a critical reading of graphs work like a pair of glasses for everyday life.

Published in 2014, the book blends the history of science, politics, sports, lotteries, and medicine. Instead of teaching calculations, the author tells stories about smart people who drew the wrong conclusions from data, then shows the reasoning that could have prevented their mistakes. Readers who spent their school years hating math are often surprised, because here numbers help you make decisions that matter.

The underlying argument is that common sense is a good starting point, but it needs reinforcement. In certain situations, such as small probabilities, trends that change direction, and comparisons between groups, intuition fails in predictable ways. In this view, mathematics is the training that corrects those failures.

The plane that returned and the one that didn't

The book's first famous example comes from World War II. The U.S. military wanted to improve the armor on its bombers and examined planes returning from missions, marking where they had the most bullet holes. The obvious idea was to reinforce those areas. Statistician Abraham Wald spotted the mistake: they were looking only at the planes that survived.

The holes in the returning planes actually showed where an aircraft could take a hit and still make it home. The areas without holes were the ones that needed armor, because planes hit there never returned. Wald's reasoning illustrates survivorship bias: looking only at those who made it through a filter and forgetting everyone who fell by the wayside.

The same mistake appears when someone tells the story of an entrepreneur who dropped out of college and got rich, ignoring the thousands who did the same thing and went broke. The question the book teaches you to ask is: what am I not seeing, and why am I not seeing it?

Not every curve is a straight line

One of the book's recurring themes is the difference between linear and nonlinear relationships. In a linear relationship, doubling the effort doubles the result. Many people think this way out of habit, but much of the world doesn't work like that. There are points where more of something stops helping and starts hurting.

The political example is the Laffer curve, the idea that some tax rate maximizes tax revenue. With a zero tax rate, the government collects nothing, and with a hundred-percent tax rate, it also collects nothing, because nobody would work just to hand everything over. So somewhere in the middle, revenue reaches its maximum. The author uses this example to show that the shape of a curve matters more than arguing for or against taxes.

The warning is against rhetoric that treats every issue as a choice between two sides, or assumes that more is always better or always worse. People who understand curves ask where we are on the curve before offering an opinion.

10 more sections and the quiz

Continue in the app

Read the whole summary, finish with the How Not to Be Wrong quiz and follow the guided Journeys. No ads in the app.

About Jordan Ellenberg

Jordan Ellenberg is a mathematics professor at the University of Wisconsin-Madison in the United States. For years, he wrote Do the Math, a column for the online magazine Slate aimed at general readers. In addition to this book, he has published the novel The Grasshopper King and the popular mathematics book Shape. His academic research focuses on number theory.

Explore

Category:
Science